Anti-gentrification activists want to keep area shit

Residents of Scuttlebridge, south-east London, have been urged to resist what campaigners call "an existential threat to the character of the community" after plans were lodged for a bakery that sells sourdough.

Anti-gentrification activists want to keep area shit

Campaigners vow to protect the boarded-up shops, broken lifts and fly-tipped mattresses that give the neighbourhood its "soul" from the threat of a bakery.

Residents of Scuttlebridge, a suburb of south-east London, have been urged to resist what campaigners call "an existential threat to the character of the community" after plans were lodged for a bakery that sells sourdough.

The Scuttlebridge Not For Sale Collective was founded in 2023 by a group of residents who moved to the area in 2021. It held an emergency meeting last night in the back room of the former Duke of Wellington pub, now a co-working space with a kombucha tap.

"People need to understand that the empty units, the burnt-out moped on Mafeking Road and the bus shelter that's been smashed since 2019 are part of Scuttlebridge's DNA," said organiser Tamsin Rook-Hadley, 34, a brand strategist who rents a converted loft in the old biscuit factory. "When outsiders arrive with their flat whites and their working streetlights, something irreplaceable is lost."

A heritage worth fighting for

The Collective's manifesto, Keep Scuttlebridge Scuttlebridge, calls for an immediate freeze on all improvements. It lists 37 "community heritage assets", including the derelict Woolworths, a bookmaker's, two vape shops and a pothole outside the Co-op that locals have affectionately named Old Gerald.

The group has also objected to a new GP surgery, describing it as "the medicalisation of the high street", and to a dentist, which it says "imposes middle-class teeth on a working-class area".

"We're not against change," Ms Rook-Hadley added. "We're against change that happens after we've arrived."

The Collective has also won backing from Stanley Farquharson III, 29, a freelance critic of art in public lavatories, who lives with his wife Charlotte-Emily in nearby Dulwich. The couple made headlines earlier this year when they bought a four-bedroom house by avoiding avocados and lattes.

"Charlotte-Emily and I know better than anyone how hard it is to get on the property ladder," said Mr Farquharson, whose deposit was topped up by an £800,000 gift from the couple's parents. "We sacrificed so much. That is precisely why we cannot allow just anyone to come in and start building more ladders."

Mrs Farquharson, who has now signed two petitions against local developments this year, added: "We do adore Scuttlebridge's gritty character. We drive through it most weekends with the doors locked."

Locals respond

Not all residents share the Collective's enthusiasm for decline. Doreen Pike, 71, has lived on the Heathcote Estate for 52 years.

"I've been asking the council to fix the lift for eleven years," she said. "Then a young man with a lanyard knocks on my door to tell me the lift is a symbol of working-class resilience and he'll chain himself to it if anyone tries to repair it. I asked if, since he was there anyway, he could carry my shopping up nine flights. He said that would be performative allyship."

Local father-of-three Winston Okafor said he had been looking forward to the bakery. "My kids think bread comes from the garage forecourt," he said. "I was told by some young white people that my wanting a croissant was internalised colonisation. I'm from Peckham."

The experts weigh in

Dr Felix Amberley-Strange, Reader in Critical Urban Studies at the School of Oriental and African Studies, said the campaign was "vital". Dr Amberley-Strange lives in a five-bedroom Victorian villa in a Hampstead conservation area, where he successfully opposed a Pret.

"Gentrification is the process by which capital erases authentic deprivation," he explained. "The ideal community is one in which everyone else remains poor in a vibrant way. Poverty is extremely authentic, especially when viewed from the top deck of a bus."

Dr Amberley-Strange dismissed a recent study by a shadowy network of economists suggesting that building more homes might reduce prices. "Supply-side dogma," he said. "Build more homes and prices might fall. Then anyone could move in, and the area would lose its exclusivity. I mean its authenticity."

Resistance becomes an amenity

The campaign suffered a setback this week when Foxleigh & Partners began marketing flats as being "in a vibrant, contested neighbourhood with a thriving anti-gentrification scene". The listing added roughly 15% to asking prices.

A Foxleigh spokesperson said: "Buyers love it. Nothing says 'up-and-coming' like a banner reading 'YUPPIES OUT' outside an artisan cheese shop."

Undeterred, the Collective has announced a street party to "reclaim" the high street. It will feature a DJ, a natural wine bar and a £14 Korean-Mexican fusion burrito stall. Asked whether this might itself constitute gentrification, Ms Rook-Hadley said: "No, because we're doing it ironically."

Members will also occupy the proposed bakery site from Saturday. Catering will be provided by a vegan café that opened on the street in March.

A compromise

In a statement, the Borough Council said it had "listened carefully to all voices" and reached a compromise. The bakery will be permitted to open on condition that all bread is sold at least three days old white sliced hovis, the shopfront remains covered in graffiti, and the staff are rude.

Enjoying this post?

If you want to read more of Paige Turner, please subscribe.

Paige Turner is a journalist with an unparalleled commitment to bringing you 'news' which you want to read regardless of its veracity, importance or relevance to your life. She entered journalism after struggling to find an alternative career.

Sign up to the OMS newsletter

Stay informed with the latest news from the most important department in the country.

Thank you for signing up.

Check your inbox and click the link to confirm your subscription.

Sorry, something went wrong. Please try again.